Authenticity is the new buzzword in business. Everyone is talking about creating an authentic brand, but what does that actually mean? What does an authentic brand look like?

For many years small businesses have been advised to look at their competition, find what is working for them and emulate those practices in their business. Unfortunately, what has manifested from this practice is that small businesses unintentionally copy competitors, chase trends, or write what they think customers want to hear. The result is a polished brand that feels interchangeable with dozens of others.

An authentic brand isn’t created by checking boxes, but by making intentional choices that reflect who you really are as a business.

Authentic Brands Aren’t Built Overnight

Every small business wants to launch the “perfect brand” from the start. Why would you not? But business is always changing and our mindset around the evolution of our business needs to be flexible. A business started ten years ago, for example, is not the same business that is operating today.

Consider your brand and business as something you grow into. There are a multitude of reasons why a business evolves over the years. Technology shifts, changing demographics, customer feedback, economic considerations, and market changes all affect how we run our business. It will also affect the overall perception of our brand.

Your first logo or website isn’t your final identity. In fact, large companies regularly update the logos and catch phrases of their brand to better reflect their current evolution. Even big names like Google, Lay’s, Honda, PepsiCo, and BMW updated their logos within the last two years.

But the big takeaway from this isn’t to give yourself permission to refine your messaging over time. Most small business owners know that, if they don’t evolve with a changing market, they will be left behind.

The big takeaway is to make changes that are in line with what you want your brand and business to represent. Authenticity grows through experience and customers appreciate businesses that evolve honestly rather than constantly reinventing themselves.

Stop Trying to Look Like a Large Business

Small businesses can feel pressured to appear larger or more established than they really are. It causes them to lean away from what is authentic about their brand.

Try to avoid:

• Corporate-sounding language on your website and marketing
• Stock photography that doesn’t represent your business
• Static mission statements that don’t tell potential clients who you truly are

And, pretending to have a large team when it’s just you and your partner boxing product in your living room is doing nothing to promote your authenticity.

For many small businesses, your authentic brand centers around being local. Celebrate that. Bring in the personal touch and lean into being small and accessible. Your business doesn’t have a dozen layers of bureaucracy that a customer has to tread through to solve a problem and that’s a good thing.

Customers often choose small businesses specifically because they’re small.

Build Your Authentic Brand Around What You Actually Do Best

As strange as it sounds, often what your business does best isn’t the product or service you sell. You may be excellent at installing windows or you bake a fantastic cookie, but other people install windows or sell cookies. So, how do you build an authentic brand around more than just what you sell?

Instead of trying to figure out: “What should our brand be?”, try to discover “What do customers already compliment us on?”

Take a good look at what your customers are saying.

Pay attention to:

• Customer Reviews
• Frequently Asked Questions
• Repeat Business
• Referral Comments

Do your customers frequently comment about how pleasant you and your staff are? Are they talking about how you go above and beyond to get a job done or how easy it is to get issues resolved? This is where you shine. Your customers will reveal your authentic strengths far better than brainstorming adjectives in a conference room.

Let Customers Shape Your Authentic Brand

If you’re particularly savvy with authenticity, you will realize that your brand isn’t just what you say it is. It’s also what people experience. And you can use what customers are saying about you to actually craft your brand.

Language matters and authentic brands pay attention to how customers describe them. They look through the reviews, testimonials, customer conversations, and social media comments and adopt the language their customers are using because they know it’s already resonating.

It is more than just taking a customer review and using it in an ad or social media post. It’s adjusting your taglines, the voice you use in your posts and promotions, and the general tone of your brand to reflect the way your customers already talk about you. It has the effect of making your brand feel more real and more approachable because you are already speaking your clients’ language.

Don’t Chase Every Trend

Every year brings new design trends, new social media platforms, new marketing advice, and new AI tools, just to name a few. It can feel like we’re always behind the curve and it’s a mad scramble to keep up with the latest in our niche.

But here is the important thing to remember:

Not every trend fits every business.

That’s worth repeating…

Not every trend fits every business, particularly when we are striving for an authentic brand.

Before adopting something new into your business, ask yourself:

• Does this fit our personality?
• Will our customers appreciate it?
• Does this make us more helpful?

If the answer is no to any one of these, then your answer to whether you should adopt the new practice should be no. It is that simple. Authenticity sometimes means saying no.

Using AI Without Losing Your Authentic Brand Voice

In this age of rapid AI growth, small business owners are going to have to flex a new skill:

When to use AI and what for.

Because, if we’re not careful, our authentic voice can easily get homogenized in a sea of AI content.

What AI is Best At

At its core, our current AI models, in any app, are generative search engines. Sure, there is automation, but AI still goes out, gathers the information requested, and creates whatever you asked for with that information.

With that in mind, AI is particularly good as:

• A brainstorming partner
• First-draft writer
• Research assistant
• Editor
• Idea generator

What AI Does Poorly

Since AI gathers a bunch of information and condenses it into usable chunks, everything starts to sound similar. This kind of generic content or customer interaction can be particularly harmful for small businesses.

When it comes to managing your authentic brand, AI should never be a stand-in for:

• Your brand personality
• Customer service
• Your About page
• Personal stories and anecdotes on any media

Practical tips

To maintain your authentic voice when using AI tools, try these:

• Rewrite everything in your own words.
• Add real examples from your business.
• Remove generic phrases.
• Include customer stories.
• Read content aloud. If it doesn’t sound like something you’d naturally say, keep editing.

*A Good Rule: If someone could paste your content onto another company’s website without changing anything, it isn’t authentic enough.

For New Businesses: Build Trust Before Recognition

When building a new business, you don’t need a recognizable brand, just a trustworthy one. Recognition comes later. Trust must come first.

Focus on:

• Delivering consistently
• Communicating honestly
• Showing your personality
• Solving customer problems
• Following through

Authenticity is built on the back of good business practices, so make these a priority.

For Established Businesses: Give Yourself Permission to Grow

Your business today probably isn’t the business you started, even if you started just a few years ago. You may have changed services, narrowed your niche, raised prices, expanded your team, or developed more expertise.

Your brand shouldn’t be static either. Authentic branding should reflect today’s business, not the one you launched years ago.

Keep in mind, refreshing your brand doesn’t mean abandoning your identity. You are simply catching your brand up to your business.

Authentic Brands Stay Consistent, Not Identical

It is easy to get stuck in the idea that our business must stay the same in order to be consistent. But consistency doesn’t mean repeating the same message forever. Building an authentic brand simply means that your customers always know what to expect.

No matter if you change your logo, your website, your colors, or your social media space, if the core experience of your business remains the same for your clients, you have remained consistent. That means your customers can count on the fact that your values, customer service, voice, and quality have not changed.

Your visuals, messaging, and marketing can evolve while your core identity remains recognizable.

A Simple Authenticity Check

Here is a quick, practical exercise to assess whether your brand and marketing are hitting the authentic mark.

When evaluating the authenticity of your market assets, ask:

• Would this sound like me if I were talking to a customer?
• Does our website reflect how we actually work?
• Are we making promises we consistently keep?
• Are we trying to impress people or genuinely help them?
• If someone met us in person after visiting our website, would the experience match?

If the answer is “no” to several of these questions, you have a clear starting point for making your brand more authentic.

Authenticity Is What Makes You Memorable

Customers rarely become loyal because a business has the trendiest logo or the cleverest slogan. They return because they know what to expect, trust your business to deliver, and they feel a connection to the people behind the brand.

As a small business owner, that’s worth its weight in gold.

Whether you’re just starting out or refining a business that’s been around for years, authenticity comes from consistently showing up as the business you truly are, not the one you think people expect.

_______

Are you struggling to bring authenticity into your branding elements? Brittakristine has years of experience creating branding elements, like logos and websites, that reflect the authenticity of your business. Let’s discuss what makes your business unique and how to translate that into a brand that speaks to you and your customers.